[Only Topic] Questions About Reviews

by Xiso on May 9th 2009, 5:27 pm

First topic message reminder :

I'm officially a question-answerer! Very Happy

Can I be? A helper? It'd be my DREAM!

Edit Eximma :
I'm making this topic an Only-Topic for questions about the review section

by Ancxy on October 22nd 2009, 3:14 am

Ok...Thank you anyway!

by **zoids25** on October 23rd 2009, 5:04 am

hmm, can i suggest if we can have templates for having specific reviews, like, if someone requests a 1-3 area (example:display/layout), a reviewer can get a specific template for display/layout only, not including about graphics, i had think this specific templates for an hour, just revised and made some changes from the last template 1.

For General:

Code:: [b][color=blue]General[/color][/b] [u]Members[/u] [b][color=green]1.Forum Activity and Member Population(Score: /10):[/color][/b] [b][color=green]2.Post Member Ratio and Quantity(Score: /10):[/color][/b] [b][color=green]3.Users Active(Score: /10):[/color][/b] [u]Staff and Groups[/u] [b][color=green]1.User Groups/Staff Groups(Score: /10):[/color][/b] [b][color=green]2.Staff Population(Score: /10):[/color][/b] [b][color=green]3.Staff Activity and Moderation(Score: /10):[/color][/b] [center][b]SCORE: /60[/b][/center]

So it will show up something like this(for general):

General

Members

1.Forum Activity and Member Population(Score: /10):

2.Post Member Ratio and Quantity(Score: /10):

3.Users Active(Score: /10):

Staff and Groups

1.User Groups/Staff Groups(Score: /10):

2.Staff Population(Score: /10):

3.Staff Activity and Moderation(Score: /10):

SCORE: /60

For Graphics,

Code:: [b][color=blue]Graphics[/color][/b] [b][color=green]1.Banner(Score: /10):[/color][/b] [b][color=green]2.Navigation Bars/Buttons(Score: /10):[/color][/b] [b][color=green]3.Images and Icons(Score: /10):[/color][/b] [center][b]SCORE: /30[/b][/center]

So it will show up something like this(for graphics):

Graphics

1.Banner(Score: /10):

2.Navigation Bars/Buttons(Score: /10):

3.Images and Icons(Score: /10):

SCORE: /30

For Display/Layout:

Code:: [b][color=blue]Display/Layout[/color][/b] [b][color=green]1. Organization and Index/Portal Appearance(Score: /10):[/color][/b] [b][color=green]2.Categories and Forums(Score: /10):[/color][/b] [b][color=green]3.Forum Colors Scheme(Score: /10):[/color][/b] [center][b]SCORE: /30[/b][/center]

So it will show this(for display/layout)

Display/Layout

1. Organization and Index/Portal Appearance(Score: /10):

2.Categories and Forums(Score: /10):

3.Forum Colors Scheme(Score: /10):

SCORE: /30

For language:

Code:: [b][color=green]Language(Score: /10):[/color][/b] [center][b]Language Total: /10[/b][/center]

for language:

Language(Score: /10):

Language Total: /10

by dotDavid on October 23rd 2009, 7:40 am

I disagree with this one: 2.Post Member Ratio and Quantity(Score: /10): as it is not always a measure on how successful your forum is, or isn't. It may help, but generally, it shouldn't be counted. A better measure would be the top few stand out posters' total posts, minus from the total, and that new amount spread among the rest of the users. That would show a better spread.

Also, I think it would be easier to make it all add up to 100.

by **zoids25** on October 23rd 2009, 7:44 am

i just made that for single reviews not for a template for another full review, i will think about these again or MrMario or Rok can think about what should be added or not or they can reject it.