Requesting review for a new forum

This forum is locked: you cannot post, reply to, or edit topics.   This topic is locked: you cannot edit posts or make replies.

View previous topic View next topic Go down

Completed Requesting review for a new forum

Post by Team101 on November 1st 2009, 2:09 pm

Name of the Forum: LFC Online Reds
Address: http://liverpoolfanszone.forumotion.com
What categories would you like the reviewer to review? I would like my forum to be generally reviewed



    This review has been completed by zoids 25.

Team101
Forumotion Member

Male
Posts: 236
Language: english
Country:
Join date: 2009-05-22

http://forumosion.forumotion.com

Back to top Go down

Completed Re: Requesting review for a new forum

Post by zoids25 on November 2nd 2009, 6:35 am

**TAGGED, i'll be starting this review later or in 24 hours.

zoids25
Forum Reviewer
Forum Reviewer

Male
Posts: 834
Age: 15
Language: English,Tagalog,a little bit of spanish and japanese.
Location: Balanga, Bataan Montessori School
Country:
Join date: 2009-08-02

http://www.pokemen.net

Back to top Go down

Completed Re: Requesting review for a new forum

Post by zoids25 on November 3rd 2009, 5:26 am

General

1.Forum Activity and Member Population (6/10):I'd seen most of the forums there are having plenty enough of posts, I'd also seen 2 forums having the latest post made yesterday and that's good, but most of the forums are having posts made last September 22 to October 31 which is almost out to date. These are forums that had been left dusted: "LFC Match Tickets & Travel" and "LFC Transfer Discussions" , there are also a total of 65 users on the forum but the posting activity is poor, Just keep promoting your forum and create interesting topics to keep the forum running.

2.Post Member Ratio and Quantity(7/10):According to the statistics page, there are 463 messages posted on the forum for 65 members, i must say its less on a forum having 65 members, if i were to estimate a forum having 60 plus members, you should have atleast 1500 messages now, if i were to divide the posts to your members, each members will get 7 posts, still looks good, as I've mentioned above, just keep creating topics that will interest members to keep it running.

3.Users Active(6/10):It's quite hard to say how many members are logging in each period if the 'members connected last x hours' is disabled but according to the statistics page, there are 5 out of 65 users being most active, less to be considered, Just keep promoting, send out weekly news letters to get the members back.

4.Staff Population:I'm really sorry but i didn't counts staff members because the 'legend groups' and the 'members connected last 24 hours' is disabled and its hard for me to identify who are the staff members on the forum.( i will not include this category)

5.UserGroups:Didn't seen any usergroups as well, I also didn't see any usergroup links on the navigation bars(i will not include this category)

Total=>19/30


Code:

[b][color=blue]General[/color][/b]

[b]1.Forum Activity and Member Population (6/10):[/b]I'd seen most of the forums there are having plenty enough of posts, I'd also seen 2 forums having the latest post made yesterday and that's good, but most of the forums are having posts made last September 22 to October 31 which is almost out to date. These are forums that had been left dusted: "LFC Match Tickets & Travel" and "LFC Transfer Discussions" , there are also a total of 65 users on the forum but the posting activity is poor, Just keep promoting your forum and create interesting topics to keep the forum running.

[b]2.Post Member Ratio and Quantity(7/10):[/b]According to the statistics page, there are 463 messages posted on the forum for 65 members, i must say its less on a forum having 65 members, if i were to estimate a forum having 60 plus members, you should have atleast 1500 messages now, if i were to divide the posts to your members, each members will get 7 posts, still looks good, as I've mentioned above, just keep creating topics that will interest members to keep it running.

[b]3.Users Active(6/10):[/b]It's quite hard to say how many members are logging in each period if the 'members connected last x hours' is disabled but according to the statistics page,  there are 5 out of 65 users being most active, less to be considered, Just keep promoting, send out weekly news letters to get the members back.

[b]4.Staff Population:[/b]I'm really sorry but i didn't counts staff members because the 'legend groups' and the 'members connected last 24 hours' is disabled and its hard for me to identify who are the staff members on the forum.( i will not include this category)

[b]5.UserGroups:[/b]Didn't seen any usergroups as well, I also didn't see any usergroup links on the navigation bars(i will not include this category)

[center][b][color=green]Total=>19/30[/color][/b][/center]


Last edited by zoids25 on November 4th 2009, 5:56 am; edited 2 times in total (Reason for editing : the code has been added)

zoids25
Forum Reviewer
Forum Reviewer

Male
Posts: 834
Age: 15
Language: English,Tagalog,a little bit of spanish and japanese.
Location: Balanga, Bataan Montessori School
Country:
Join date: 2009-08-02

http://www.pokemen.net

Back to top Go down

Completed Re: Requesting review for a new forum

Post by Rok on November 5th 2009, 7:58 pm

Nice job on the review, zoids. Wink




Since this review request appears to be complete, I will now lock this thread and move it to the Review Archives section.

`-> Review Complete
`-> Moved to Review Archives

_________________



Forum Reviews:
  1. Tips for your forum
  2. Helpful information
  3. Point-outs on forum mistakes
  4. Personal comments / opinions / perspectives

Rok
Forum Reviewer
Forum Reviewer

Male
Posts: 5432
Age: 15
Language: English, HTML, a little CSS, Guitar Chords
Location: Support forum
Country:
Join date: 2008-09-14

http://forumansion.com

Back to top Go down

View previous topic View next topic Back to top


Permissions of this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum