reply for a certain comment
+2
Demonspike
Barbus
6 posters
Page 1 of 1
Would it be useful?
reply for a certain comment
Hi,
I'm looking for a possibility whether there is....to reply for a certain comment without quoting all the previous message, so instead of long quotes we would use the number and the author of the previous comment as a link (pointing to the previous command) with a button as "previous"
I think the best solution is, not a single "answer" button in the top and/or the bottom of the site, but a lots of answer buttons in all the commandboxes, said "reply to this certain command"
without this, it's so much harder following the thread of the different conversations ...
sorry because my english, I hope I expressed myself clearly enough:-))
Thanx a lot!!!!
i really like this forum, you did great job!!!
here is a sample....sorry it is hungarian
netboard forum
válasz erre=reply to this command
előzmény=previous command
I'm looking for a possibility whether there is....to reply for a certain comment without quoting all the previous message, so instead of long quotes we would use the number and the author of the previous comment as a link (pointing to the previous command) with a button as "previous"
I think the best solution is, not a single "answer" button in the top and/or the bottom of the site, but a lots of answer buttons in all the commandboxes, said "reply to this certain command"
without this, it's so much harder following the thread of the different conversations ...
sorry because my english, I hope I expressed myself clearly enough:-))
Thanx a lot!!!!
i really like this forum, you did great job!!!
here is a sample....sorry it is hungarian
netboard forum
válasz erre=reply to this command
előzmény=previous command
Re: reply for a certain comment
I'm going to say "NO" to this.
My reason being, all you have to do is click the 'Quote' button and then edit out the bits you don't want.
So if you quote two/three people's quotes, get the bits you want to emphasise your point you are making in your posts and delete the rest OR.. highlight the parts you want to make your point about.. OR make them into individual quotes and reply to all underneath.
My reason being, all you have to do is click the 'Quote' button and then edit out the bits you don't want.
So if you quote two/three people's quotes, get the bits you want to emphasise your point you are making in your posts and delete the rest OR.. highlight the parts you want to make your point about.. OR make them into individual quotes and reply to all underneath.
Re: reply for a certain comment
Demonspike wrote:I'm going to say "NO" to this.
My reason being, all you have to do is click the 'Quote' button and then edit out the bits you don't want.
So if you quote two/three people's quotes, get the bits you want to emphasise your point you are making in your posts and delete the rest OR.. highlight the parts you want to make your point about.. OR make them into individual quotes and reply to all underneath.
Ok, I don't know why would be that big poblem for U anther solution, and another button with it...if U don't want to use it so don't do!!!
Yes, my problem is the same that u wrote as an advantage:
I don't want to see the previous message in my comment box....if U inerested in U can easily find the previous one, and the previous one, and etc...but otherwise it's a waste of space, I think.
How could you easily follow the thread of a conversation....sometimes it goes through 15-20 comments....U wanna do with quote in quote, or just quote the last one, and after it...I really don't know how to look for the previous one.....
and sorry if I seem a little bit constant, but we use this form in another forum for years, and our topic has soooo much biger life then others I read....it means...411068. commands in one topic..... so believe me it works....
using such a type of forums U need so much more topics, to chat about a certain thing....we can chat about anything...in only one topic, so we cannot separate, and consequently we became a great forum group, and a great gang in real life....
Re: reply for a certain comment
my comment became much bigger then without "quote"....and we would replace it with a comment number as a link...and U wouldn't have to edit the quote also...
Re: reply for a certain comment
I voted Yes as its always nice to have forums updated with new stuff, it gives the founder and the admins something to do.
Guest- Guest
Re: reply for a certain comment
Thanx so muchwildkat wrote:I voted Yes as its always nice to have forums updated with new stuff, it gives the founder and the admins something to do.
Re: reply for a certain comment
Demonspike wrote:I'm going to say "NO" to this.
My reason being, all you have to do is click the 'Quote' button and then edit out the bits you don't want.
I just did so and I agree.
Re: reply for a certain comment
Barbus wrote:
Ok, I don't know why would be that big poblem for U anther solution, and another button with it...if U don't want to use it so don't do!!!
Easy -
Barbus wrote:Yes, my problem is the same that u wrote as an advantage:
I don't want to see the previous message in my comment box....if U inerested in U can easily find the previous one, and the previous one, and etc...but otherwise it's a waste of space, I think.
Just -
Barbus wrote:How could you easily follow the thread of a conversation....sometimes it goes through 15-20 comments....U wanna do with quote in quote, or just quote the last one, and after it...I really don't know how to look for the previous one.....
Like -
Barbus wrote:and sorry if I seem a little bit constant, but we use this form in another forum for years, and our topic has soooo much biger life then others I read....it means...411068. commands in one topic..... so believe me it works....
using such a type of forums U need so much more topics, to chat about a certain thing....we can chat about anything...in only one topic, so we cannot separate, and consequently we became a great forum group, and a great gang in real life....
This -
See how easy it is, took me 30 seconds to quote all those... Easily done.. so "NO"
Re: reply for a certain comment
Demonspike wrote:Barbus wrote:
Ok, I don't know why would be that big poblem for U anther solution, and another button with it...if U don't want to use it so don't do!!!
Easy -Barbus wrote:Yes, my problem is the same that u wrote as an advantage:
I don't want to see the previous message in my comment box....if U inerested in U can easily find the previous one, and the previous one, and etc...but otherwise it's a waste of space, I think.
Just -Barbus wrote:How could you easily follow the thread of a conversation....sometimes it goes through 15-20 comments....U wanna do with quote in quote, or just quote the last one, and after it...I really don't know how to look for the previous one.....
Like -Barbus wrote:and sorry if I seem a little bit constant, but we use this form in another forum for years, and our topic has soooo much biger life then others I read....it means...411068. commands in one topic..... so believe me it works....
using such a type of forums U need so much more topics, to chat about a certain thing....we can chat about anything...in only one topic, so we cannot separate, and consequently we became a great forum group, and a great gang in real life....
This -
See how easy it is, took me 30 seconds to quote all those... Easily done.. so "NO"
you're right........
Re: reply for a certain comment
bob8972 wrote:Sorry but what would be the difference? Vote=No
I think I wrote about the difference...I don't think that I should write again and again....please read my comments
Re: reply for a certain comment
Suggestion Clean up -> Old suggestions(Please feel to create a new thread for the garbaged old suggestions) -> Implemented & Rejected suggestions -> Suggestions which are currently suggested (Please use the SEARCH function) -> Unclear Suggestions => Please read the guidelines for the suggestion section: https://help.forumotion.com/t93899-suggestions-for-your-forums-how-to => Please take a look on the frequently suggested features for your forums: https://help.forumotion.com/t79095-frequently-requested-suggestions-for-your-forums Locked & Garbaged Jophy |
Jophy- ForumGuru
- Posts : 17924
Reputation : 836
Language : English
Location : Somewhere
Similar topics
» differences background between comment reply & profile reply
» Have not got post new comment or reply buttons Please Help
» Change the ''Quick reply'' text to ''Add Comment''
» Quick Reply and Reply alignment issues
» When onclick button of "Post Reply" scroll down to the quick reply
» Have not got post new comment or reply buttons Please Help
» Change the ''Quick reply'' text to ''Add Comment''
» Quick Reply and Reply alignment issues
» When onclick button of "Post Reply" scroll down to the quick reply
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum