Best of ForuMotion 2011: The Winners

Best of ForuMotion 2011 : Winners Congratulations to our winners, and condolences do the not so successful.

Hello All,


We, the judges have a few things we'd like to say before we announce our winners

This year's competition was definitively a very hard competition, from the hundreds of forums to choose from, to the consistent bickering, however, all through it we were able to come to an outstanding result, one that we are proud of, and that the community as a whole is proud of, and we'll be proud to showboat our winners in their own special way

On a personal note, I did find it difficult because there were several great forums that I'd personally love to see win, however, because it was only great in one of 3 criterion's, they were unable to succeed. I quite enjoyed some of the friendly discussion and the competitiveness of our forums this year.

Now to build some suspense

Here's a quick reminder on our top 5 forums, all being linked to their respective sites, in no particular order.

• Babies & All
  
• Unded Xbox
  
• WebArtz
  
• GeekPolice
  
• World Dezign
  

This year, we've decided to rid ourselves of the traditional prizes and step it up a notch, or three.

All of our top 5 forums will be receiving a particular small logo, as well as a nice treat for our top 2

1. First place:
   as well as a nicely sized mention on www.forumotion.com !
   
   
2. Second place:
   As well as a interview from us here at the Support Forum!
   
   
3. Third place:
   
   
5. Fourth & Fifth place will also receive an Honorable mention!
   

And now the anticipation is over, and here I announce the winners.
A personal congratulations from myself, and my fellow judges.

1. Congratulations Lisa1302! First place.
   Babies & All, http://www.babiesandall.com/
   
   as well as a nicely sized mention on www.forumotion.com !
   
   
2. Congratulations Gangster15! Second place.
   World Dezign, http://www.worlddezign.com/
   
   As well as a interview from us here at the Support Forum!
   
   
3. Congratulations Doctor Inferno! Third place.
   GeekPolice, http://GeekPolice.net
   
   
   
4. Congratulations Sanket Forth place!
   WebArtz Forum, http://www.webartzforum.com/
   
   
   
5. Congratulations viho1! Fifth place.
   Undead Xbox, www.undead-xbox.com
   
   

Congratulations to you all, you all deserve your places, it took us many many hours of discussions, but we eventually agreed on these places

I'd also like to take this chance to say that as of now, I am handing down the green baton of ensuring this competition continues to thrive, putting it back into it's black box, and locking it back up and into it's locker, for the final time.
I wish my successor much luck.
Thank you to everyone, including Typlo, MrMario, Tilum, Base and various other staff for their ongoing assistance with the competition thought the years.



Many thanks,
Darren.

Well done to all those who have participated. I must say, everyone has put it a lot of effort into this and every single forum which entered this competition has a lot of potential. I give my condolences, as well as the judging panel, to all those who didn't quite make it.

I would like to take this opportunity to thank all the people who have voted for WebArtz. Your love has been unconditional for us.

Whatever criterion the judges have decided upon, they have conducted a really good competition. Great work guys

Thank you so much voters and judges!!!! I am over the moon!
Well done everyone, fab forums in the top 5!!!!!

Congratulations!

Sanket wrote:I would like to take this opportunity to thank all the people who have voted for WebArtz. Your love has been unconditional for us.

Whatever criterion the judges have decided upon, they have conducted a really good competition. Great work guys

We have all put an effort. Congrats to us!

Congratulations to all (:

WOW well done BANDA!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Well done to lisa and all at banda.

Also well done to all the forums that made it into the top 5!

Well done banda xx

Congratulations to everybody who took part in the competition!

All of the forums are great and you should be proud.

Congrats to all

Congrats to all!
and thanks for who voted for WD!

What?

Despite the fact that this is ridiculous, UndeadXbox is supposed to be in the top 3 AT LEAST. Last round was to decide the top 3, and we came 2nd place in votes. How the hell is this a legitimate contest?

From Undead Xbox.

Very very disappointed with how this all played out.

You said that the top three would be moving on. UX was in the top three and ended up getting fifth place. There is no logic to this contest at all.

Can someone explain this to me because, in my eyes, it seems like very poor judging to change the rules multiple times throughout the contest.

In fact, you didn't even spell our name right.

To continue, you changed the rules in Round 2 and Round 4, and I can't fathom why. Is it because you have some predilection for or against some forums?

How is this a legitimate contest when rules are so arbitrary and subject to change that there's really no point in entering in the first place?

Seriously Forum Mods, this is ridiculous. I want an explanation via PM or whatever means.

congratulation gogo (worlddezign) .. u are the best but the small number of members couldn't help .. next year we shall rock it

I agree with SuperMegaKing. This makes no sense. We were [like he said] guaranteed at least 3rd place yet we end up with 5th?

I dont understand how that works.

Dear Forumotion Contest Judges,

I am deeply disappointed at the final ranking of this contest. I feel as if the rules and regulations of this contest have changed several times throughout this competition, all of which I've noticed hurt UX's running in the contest. We're weren't here to be the bad guys. For example, Geek Police has hardly given this contest much thought on their forums, and despite their extremely active forum they only had 5 votes last round. I hadn't realized the extent that voting in this contest by site's members didn't matter at all. As a suggestion to next year's contest, remove the previous three rounds and just make a decision, because rounds 2-4 didn't matter. I don't think it made a difference.

Also, can we at least have some notes, information, or opinions that lead to each site's position in the contest? I'd at least like to see suggestions for improvement of UX's site as well as reasons why other site's performed better than ours. Using this information I'd like to improve the site to fit what the Judges would like to see in a forum for next year's competition.

Thank you,
-Meatshield718
UX Administrator

Hi all, I can assure you that the decisions made are right. Of course Undead Xbox had a significant number of votes however it's not just votes that contributed to the overall outcome. We as the judges had our reasons behind our decision and it's too late to change anything now.

Can't see how any of these decisions were made right. I can point out about six occurences where it seemed as if you guys had no idea how a contest worked. Still want that explanation.

The votes were there to aid in the decision - maybe how the voting was 'encouraged' and how the members of every forum behaved came into it too - there is no way that votes alone could decide this one - bearing in mind UX offered a raffle for those who entered - the members didn't necessarily vote to show their support for the forum, maybe they did it for the raffle prize?
Seriously though, whinging about losing is really sad ...this isn't xbox live chat!

Correct. The votes only aided our decision. If the results were completely based on votes then it wouldn't be fair at all. Remember: it's quality not quantity. As we previously said all forums are not to go away empty handed and that we fully acknowledge that all forums have put a lot of effort into this contest.

lisa1302 wrote:The votes were there to aid in the decision - maybe how the voting was 'encouraged' and how the members of every forum behaved came into it too - there is no way that votes alone could decide this one - bearing in mind UX offered a raffle for those who entered - the members didn't necessarily vote to show their support for the forum, maybe they did it for the raffle prize?
Seriously though, whinging about losing is really sad ...this isn't xbox live chat!

As a participant in the contest, I'm astounded that you're not similarly outraged at the amount of arbitrary changes that occurred during the contest. I suppose it's because you won?

I can deal with the fact that Undead Xbox lost. I can't really fathom that the contest was changed so much that it seems very unprofessional and ridiculous.

Winner not based on votes: Okay, I understand that, but why advertise that "the top three would move on" or, as in Round 2, "the top five would move on" if you actually had no intention of any of that happening.

We aren't complaining that we lost, and we aren't complaining that winning wasn't based on votes; we're complaining that the contest was not very fair with anyone because the rules were not clear and the Rounds were arbitrary.

Hi,

I understand some of you have concerns/complaints. Feel free to register on http://bestoffm.forumotion.com/ if you would like a response. Please dont complain here - it's a topic for congratulations rather than complaints.

~ Tilum

No, it isn't because I won - it's because its a fun competition that I entered without thinking I had a chance to win - because we all believe in our forums, but its how people from the outside see our forums that was important here too - and to be honest the teensy little changes the judges made to contest made no difference to the outcome/

So what do you think would have changed had the judges not made slight changes to the way the contest was run? You think you'd have deserved to come in the top 3 simply because you offered an incentive to your members?

All you are doing by complaining is trying to belittle the contest - and yes we have all read you comments on your forum - however you won't ruin it for everyone else, despite your attempts.

lisa1302 wrote:The votes were there to aid in the decision - maybe how the voting was 'encouraged' and how the members of every forum behaved came into it too - there is no way that votes alone could decide this one - bearing in mind UX offered a raffle for those who entered - the members didn't necessarily vote to show their support for the forum, maybe they did it for the raffle prize?
Seriously though, whinging about losing is really sad ...this isn't xbox live chat!

Thanks for considering me as one step lower than you for enjoying video games. I'm a real person too, not an adolescent that cannot understand why a site for parents to meet and ask questions is a great idea. It definitely is, and you have a wonderful site; Just don't lower any of our staff as people for creating a non-business forum. I'm not here to whine, I'm just here for the betterment of my forum, Thank you.

@Base
I understand that your final decision was in no way formed against UX. It just seemed odd to me how much the rules changed around throughout the event. It worried me because half the time I didn't understand where the results were exactly coming from.

I know that this forum does a bit of "Forum Rating or Grading" and has a nice system of rating a forum based on many different factors. Did you guys do any of those for the top five? UX has been in one before, and I'd like to see where we've improved or fell short upon, and I'd like to see the information behind where other site's preformed better than our own.

Thanks!

EDIT*
@ Tilum, I created an account on the forum you suggested we moved this conversation to, and I am now waiting for admin admission.

Sorry Tilum, I posted as you did.

EDIT: Dont worry about it
~ Tilum

lisa1302 wrote:No, it isn't because I won - it's because its a fun competition that I entered without thinking I had a chance to win - because we all believe in our forums, but its how people from the outside see our forums that was important here too - and to be honest the teensy little changes the judges made to contest made no difference to the outcome/

So what do you think would have changed had the judges not made slight changes to the way the contest was run? You think you'd have deserved to come in the top 3 simply because you offered an incentive to your members?

All you are doing by complaining is trying to belittle the contest - and yes we have all read you comments on your forum - however you won't ruin it for everyone else, despite your attempts.

I find it really disappointing that several people from UX supported you and the members of Banda, even protested against the possibility of you being suspended. And you were a good sport all the way through, but as soon as you win, you start talking shit about everyone that lost.


Grow up.