Admin: No notice rec'd to approve registrant

I set up the forum to notify me to approve new registrants. The first one registered, got the email with confirmation link, clicked it and it said "not a known member". I assume this was because she wasn't approved. The ONLY way I could get her in is to upgrade her to moderator. I did also check my spam folder - no notice on the new registrant.

I am getting notices of everything else by email - just not new registrant for approval.

Thanks.

Users & groups>USers options
New accounts activation : Do you have it set as admin?

Sanket -

Yes, thanks. I have both the following set for Admin as follows:

New accounts activation : Automatic activation User Admin Send notify
Email on new user registrations : None Moderator Admin

Do the mails by any chance go into spam?